Chapter IV  ·  726 – 843

The Image
controversies.

Two iconoclast periods, the political theology of religious imagery, and the restoration of the icons that produced medieval Orthodoxy.

10 min read

The dispute over the religious veneration of figural images of Christ, the Virgin, the saints and the angels was the principal internal controversy of the eastern Empire from the early eighth to the mid-ninth century, and one of the doctrinal-political confrontations of the medieval Christian world. The dispute is misunderstood when read as a purely theological question: it was also a question of imperial-ecclesiastical relations, of monastic-secular power, of cultural-confessional self-identification against the Islamic and the Jewish neighbours, of the imperial revenue (the monasteries that defended the icons owned a proportion of imperial land), and of the doctrinal-philosophical heritage of late antiquity. The two iconoclast periods — 726–787 under Leo III and Constantine V (the Isaurian dynasty) and 815–843 under Leo V, Michael II and Theophilus (the Amorian dynasty) — produced a hundred and seventeen years of religious-political conflict before the final restoration of the icons under the Empress Theodora in 843.

The theology of the image

The doctrinal question was whether the visual representation of holy persons constituted a legitimate object of religious veneration or an idolatrous violation of the Old-Testament prohibition of graven images. The iconophile position — developed by John of Damascus (c. 675–749) and the Second Council of Nicaea (787) — was that the Incarnation of Christ as God-made-man had sanctified the representation of holy persons in physical form, that the veneration directed at the image ascended to the prototype, and that the visual icon was the visual equivalent of the verbal Scripture. The iconoclast position — developed by Constantine V in his Peuseis ("Questions") of around 750 and codified by the Council of Hieria of 754 — was that any attempt to circumscribe the divine nature of Christ in a physical image either denied his divinity (if it depicted only the human nature) or improperly conflated the two natures (if it claimed to depict both), and that the proper Christian visual culture was abstract and non-figural.

The political dimension

The political dimension was the imperial-ecclesiastical balance of power. The iconoclast emperors of the Isaurian dynasty — Leo III (717–741), Constantine V (741–775) and Leo IV (775–780) — were successful military emperors who had stabilised the Anatolian frontier against the Arabs, conducted administrative reform, and exercised caesaropapist control over the imperial church. The iconoclast policy was, at one level of analysis, the assertion of imperial authority against the autonomy of the monastic establishments and the patriarchal administration. The iconophile resistance — particularly the monastic resistance led by Theodore the Studite (759–826) and the Studium monastery at Constantinople — was correspondingly the defence of ecclesiastical autonomy against imperial encroachment.

The first iconoclast period (726–787)

The occasion of the policy was Leo III's edict of around 726 ordering the removal of the icon of Christ over the Chalke gate of the imperial palace, followed by a sequence of progressively more measures: the imperial edict of 730 mandating the destruction of religious images in churches, the conflict with Pope Gregory II at Rome (which contributed to the eventual breach between the imperial church and the Roman papacy), the Council of Hieria of 754 (under Constantine V) which formally condemned image-veneration, the persecution of iconophile monks during the 760s and 770s, and the expropriation of monastic property.

The first iconoclast period was terminated by the regency of the Empress Irene for her young son Constantine VI in the 780s. The Second Council of Nicaea, convened in 787 under Irene's direction, formally rehabilitated image-veneration and condemned the Council of Hieria. The restoration was, however, fragile: Irene's political missteps, her conflicts with the army (which was iconoclast in sympathy), her blinding and deposition of her own son Constantine VI in 797 (the only case of mother-on-son violence in the imperial succession), and her own deposition in 802 by the finance minister Nicephorus, set the conditions for an iconoclast revival under the Amorian dynasty.

Manuscript miniature of the martyrdom of Euthymius of Sardis.
Persecution of the iconophilesA Madrid Skylitzes miniature shows the death of Euthymius of Sardis, one of the bishops who resisted the imperial ban on icons.

The second iconoclast period (815–843)

The occasion of the revival was the military defeat of Michael I by the Bulgar khan Krum at Versinikia in June 813, which produced the political assessment among the army leadership that the iconophile policy had brought divine disfavour on the imperial military. Leo V the Armenian, who deposed Michael I a month later, restored the iconoclast position by the Council of 815. The second iconoclast period under Leo V (813–820), Michael II the Amorian (820–829) and Theophilus (829–842) was less violent in its persecutions than the first — because the iconophile monasteries had learned to operate clandestinely, and because the political-religious passions had diminished. The doctrinal controversies of the period were prosecuted by a smaller cast of figures — Theodore the Studite and the Patriarch Nicephorus on the iconophile side, John VII the Grammarian on the iconoclast side — and produced pamphlet literature but limited popular violence.

Chludov Psalter detail likening iconoclasm to the Crucifixion.
The Chludov PsalterA 9th-century iconophile manuscript likens the whitewashing of an icon of Christ to the soldiers offering vinegar at the Crucifixion.

The Triumph of Orthodoxy

The second restoration of the icons was effected by the Empress Theodora, the widow of Theophilus and the regent for her young son Michael III, in March 843. The liturgical commemoration of the restoration — the "Triumph of Orthodoxy", celebrated on the first Sunday of Great Lent in the Orthodox calendar — has been observed every year since 843 and continues to be observed by the Eastern Orthodox churches. The doctrinal-confessional content of the Triumph of Orthodoxy synaxarion — which lists the heretics and heresies that the Orthodox tradition has condemned — has defined the boundaries of the Orthodox confessional identity from 843 to the present.

The legacy

The cultural-religious consequence of the iconoclast controversies was the standardisation of the Orthodox visual tradition that emerged from the second restoration: the highly stylised, two-dimensional, theologically-disciplined icon tradition that the surviving sixth-century Sinai monastery images and the post-843 Byzantine production exemplify. The ecclesiastical-political consequence was the consolidation of the patriarchal-monastic establishment as an autonomous force in the imperial state, capable of resisting imperial policy on doctrinal matters — a precedent that would matter throughout the subsequent eight hundred years of the Empire's history.

The political consequence for the relationship between the eastern Empire and the Roman papacy was the estrangement that the controversies had produced, and which the Carolingian alliance of Pope Leo III with Charlemagne (December 800) had formalised. The coronation of Charlemagne as a substantively rival Roman emperor in the West was the Roman papal response to the perceived heresy of the iconoclast eastern empire. The subsequent division between the Latin and Greek churches — which would crystallise in the 1054 schism — has its origins in the iconoclast controversies of the eighth and ninth centuries.

What was actually destroyed

The conventional account has imperial officials moving through the empire for a century systematically smashing images, and it rests almost entirely on sources written by the winners after the controversy ended. Recent work on the archaeology and the surviving material has made that picture much harder to sustain.

There was certainly official iconoclasm. Leo III removed the image of Christ from the Chalke gate of the palace around 726; Constantine V called a council at Hiereia in 754 that condemned images outright; and monasteries that resisted were closed, their abbots exiled and in some cases executed. The removal of figural decoration from Hagia Irene and its replacement with a plain cross is direct physical evidence.

But the destruction seems to have been concentrated in the capital and in Constantinople's immediate orbit, and to have been aimed at monumental public images rather than at private devotion. Provincial churches in Cappadocia and the Levant kept painting figures throughout. Portable icons survived in numbers at St Catherine's on Sinai, which lay outside imperial control under Muslim rule and is the reason the pre-iconoclast tradition can be studied at all.

What the controversy did destroy was less the images than the settlement between emperor and church. Both sides discovered that doctrine could be imposed and then reversed by imperial decree, and neither forgot it. The victory of the icons in 843 is still celebrated in the Orthodox calendar as the Triumph of Orthodoxy, and the feast is about the limits of imperial authority as much as about painting.


End of Chapter IV