They called themselves Byzantines.
False
They called themselves Rhomaioi — Romans — for the entire eleven hundred years, and they called their state Basileia ton Rhomaion, the empire of the Romans. Their neighbours agreed: the Arabs called them Rum, and the Seljuk state in Anatolia was the Sultanate of Rum, meaning the sultanate in Roman territory.
The word Byzantine was coined in 1557 by the German scholar Hieronymus Wolf, from Byzantion, the Greek town Constantine built his city on. It was adopted because Western Europe had its own Holy Roman Empire and could not concede that the Roman one was still running in the East.
Calling them Byzantines is a piece of Western political score-settling that has become a scholarly convention. It is used in this volume because the alternative is confusing, but it is worth knowing that no one described in these pages would have recognised it.
“Byzantine” means needlessly complicated bureaucracy.
Mostly false
The pejorative comes from Montesquieu, Gibbon and Voltaire, who needed a counter-example of despotism and decline to argue against, and it stuck so hard that the adjective now means labyrinthine in every European language.
The empire was certainly administered. It had a treasury, a land registry, a career civil service, salaried judges, a state monopoly on silk, standardised weights and a gold coin — the nomisma — that held its purity for seven hundred years and functioned as the reserve currency of the Mediterranean. That is not decadence; it is competence, and it is why the state survived catastrophes that destroyed its neighbours.
The bureaucracy was also smaller than the reputation. Estimates put the central administration in the ninth century at around 600 officials, for an empire of perhaps ten million people. Modern states run considerably heavier.
It was a long, slow, thousand-year decline.
False
Gibbon's title — The Decline and Fall — covers the years 98 to 1590 and has shaped the whole subject. It is not a description of what happened.
The empire lost three quarters of its territory between 630 and 720 to the Arab conquests, and then recovered. Under the Macedonian dynasty from 867 to 1056 it expanded steadily, reconquered Crete, Cyprus, Antioch and Bulgaria, and reached its greatest wealth and territorial extent since Justinian. Basil II died in 1025 ruling from the Danube to Syria.
The collapse when it came was sudden: Manzikert in 1071 lost Anatolia in a decade, and the Fourth Crusade in 1204 destroyed the state. Between those disasters came the Komnenian restoration, which very nearly worked.
The shape is not a slope. It is a series of near-death experiences followed by recoveries, and then one from which there was no recovery.
Greek fire was an early form of napalm, and the recipe is lost.
Partly true, but more complicated than that
It existed, it worked, and it was decisive — twice, against Arab fleets besieging Constantinople in 678 and 717–718. It burned on water, it was projected under pressure through bronze siphons mounted in the bows of ships, and it terrified everyone who met it.
The recipe is genuinely lost, and was already a state secret at the time: Constantine VII wrote that it had been delivered by an angel and that anyone divulging it should be anathematised. The best modern guess is a petroleum distillate, probably from surface seeps around the Black Sea, thickened with resin and possibly with sulphur, delivered heated and pressurised.
The comparison with napalm is loose. Napalm is a thickened petroleum gel designed to stick and burn; Greek fire was a pumped liquid flamethrower, and the engineering of the pump was probably the harder secret than the chemistry.
The Great Schism happened in 1054 and split the church.
Mostly false
In July 1054 a papal legate laid a bull of excommunication on the altar of Hagia Sophia, aimed at the patriarch personally; the patriarch excommunicated the legates in return. The pope who had sent them was already dead, which arguably invalidated the whole thing.
Nobody at the time thought the churches had separated. Communion between East and West continued in places for another century and a half, marriages and embassies went on as before, and there had been earlier schisms — the Acacian schism of 484 to 519 lasted thirty-five years and is barely remembered.
What actually separated the churches was 1204, when a Latin crusade sacked Constantinople, installed a Latin patriarch and ruled the city for fifty-seven years. After that, reunion councils at Lyon in 1274 and Florence in 1439 both produced agreements that the Byzantine population refused to accept. The date everyone learns is a convenient marker for a process that took four hundred years.
Constantinople fell because the empire was weak and corrupt.
Mostly false
By 1453 the empire consisted of the city, a strip of Thrace and the Despotate of the Morea, with a population perhaps a tenth of what it had been. It was weak. But that weakness was the consequence of 1204 and of the Black Death, not of moral failure.
The siege itself was not a walkover. Constantine XI had perhaps 7,000 men, including 700 Genoese under Giovanni Giustiniani, against something between 60,000 and 80,000. The walls held for fifty-three days against the largest artillery train yet assembled — Mehmed's Hungarian gunfounder Orban built a bombard that took sixty oxen to move and could fire seven times a day.
The city fell when Giustiniani was wounded and withdrew, and a postern in the Blachernae section was found open. Constantine took off his imperial insignia and went into the breach; his body was never identified. That is not a description of collapse from within.
It was a Greek empire.
Mostly false
Greek was the language of administration from the seventh century, of the church throughout, and of most of the population in the core provinces. In that sense the label is fair.
But the empire was never a nation-state and would have found the idea unintelligible. Its emperors included Illyrians, Thracians, Isaurians, Armenians, Syrians and at least one Arab; the Macedonian dynasty was probably Armenian. Its armies used Armenians, Georgians, Slavs, Turks, Normans, and from the tenth century a household guard of Scandinavians and, after 1066, exiled Anglo-Saxons. Its provinces spoke Syriac, Coptic, Armenian, Slavonic, Latin and Arabic.
What made someone a Roman was orthodoxy, allegiance to the emperor, and Greek as the public language — not ancestry. Modern Greek nationalism claimed the empire in the nineteenth century, and the claim has coloured the subject ever since.
The Byzantines preserved classical learning but did nothing with it.
False
The preservation is real and enormous: virtually every classical Greek text that survives does so because Byzantine scribes copied it, and the ninth-century switch to minuscule script — which made copying faster and cheaper — saved the corpus at a moment when it was close to being lost.
But they were not merely custodians. Photios's Bibliotheca in the ninth century is a work of critical reading covering 280 books, many now lost. Michael Psellos revived Platonic philosophy in the eleventh. Anna Komnene wrote the Alexiad, a full-scale narrative history by a woman, in the twelfth. Byzantine medicine ran hospitals with specialised wards and salaried physicians centuries before anywhere in the West.
And the transmission was active at the end: Greek scholars leaving for Italy in the fifteenth century, Plethon at the Council of Florence above all, are a direct cause of the Renaissance's recovery of Plato.
The empire ended in 1453.
Partly true, but more complicated than that
The city fell on the 29th of May 1453 and the last emperor died in the fighting. But Byzantine territory did not all fall with it. The Despotate of the Morea held out until 1460, and the Empire of Trebizond on the Black Sea until 1461 — so the last Roman state expired eight years after the capital.
Institutionally, the ecumenical patriarchate continued under Ottoman rule and continues today in the Fener district of Istanbul, with an unbroken succession. Mehmed II appointed the next patriarch himself, six months after the conquest, and gave the Orthodox community a legal standing that lasted four centuries.
The claim was also inherited. Ivan III of Moscow married Constantine XI's niece in 1472, adopted the double-headed eagle, and by 1510 a Russian monk was writing that Moscow was the third Rome and that a fourth there would not be.
The Fourth Crusade got lost on the way to Jerusalem.
False
It has often been told as an accident — a crusade blown off course by debt and circumstance. The sequence does not read like an accident.
The crusaders contracted with Venice for shipping they could not pay for. Venice, under the ninety-year-old and blind Doge Enrico Dandolo, proposed that they work off the debt by taking the Christian city of Zara on the Adriatic, which they did in 1202, and were excommunicated for. A Byzantine pretender then offered money and troops to be installed in Constantinople. When he was installed and could not pay, the army stormed the city on the 12th and 13th of April 1204 and sacked it for three days.
Venice, which had commercial grievances against Constantinople going back decades, took three-eighths of the empire and the choicest relics, and its own quarter in the city. Innocent III condemned the whole business and was ignored. Whatever the intentions at the outset, the outcome was not a mistake anybody hurried to reverse.