Chapter VI  ·  945 – 1055

The Buyid
amirs.

The Daylamite Shia who entered Baghdad in 945, reduced the Sunni caliph to a religious figurehead, and held the central caliphate for a century.

10 min read

The century between the Buyid entry into Baghdad in December 945 and the Seljuk Turkish replacement of them in December 1055 is the period during which the Abbasid caliphate was held in formal religious sovereignty by a Sunni caliph at Baghdad whose substantive political authority was limited to ceremonial functions, with the actual government conducted by a Shia military dynasty of Persian provincial origin. The constitutional anomaly — a Shia military regime governing in the name of a Sunni caliph it did not theologically recognise — was sustained for a hundred and ten years by the political utility of the formal continuity to both parties and by the absence of alternative arrangements that either party could enforce.

The Daylamites

The Buyid family was of Daylamite origin — a Persian mountain population from the southern shore of the Caspian, known to the period as professional soldiers and as recent and partial converts to Shia Islam. The three founding brothers — Ali (later Imad al-Dawla), Hasan (later Rukn al-Dawla), and Ahmad (later Mu'izz al-Dawla) — had served as mercenaries in the wars of the early tenth century between competing Persian and Iraqi factions and had progressively established themselves as territorial princes in western Iran during the 930s and 940s. By 945 they controlled most of western Iran, Fars, and the route to Iraq.

The entry of Ahmad Mu'izz al-Dawla into Baghdad on the 17th of December 945 was uncontested. The caliph al-Mustakfi — whom the dispossessed Turkish guard at Baghdad had been unable to defend — received Mu'izz al-Dawla in the palace and conferred on him the title of amir al-umara ("amir of amirs"), the existing formal title for the chief executive officer of the caliphate. Ahmad's brothers received parallel titles for their territorial governments in Iran. Within weeks the relationship between the caliph and his new chief executive had been clarified: Mu'izz al-Dawla blinded al-Mustakfi and replaced him with the more accommodating al-Muti (946–974), and from that point forward the caliph's role was ceremonial.

Map of the Buyid realm about 970.
The Buyid realmThe territories of the Buyid amirs about 970, when they controlled Baghdad and held the caliph as a figurehead.

The constitutional arrangement

The Buyid-Abbasid relationship operated on a clear division of functions. The caliph retained: the formal religious sovereignty, in the sense that the Friday sermon was conducted in his name across all territories that recognised the Buyid amirs; the formal legitimating authority for new appointments, treaties and political decisions, in the sense that the documents required the caliphal seal; the ceremonial functions of the caliphal court (the audiences, the formal investitures, the Friday sermon and pilgrimage observances); and a private financial endowment from the caliphal lands. The caliph did not retain: any independent military force, any independent administrative apparatus, any independent revenue, or any practical capacity to act against the will of the amir.

The amir held the substantive political authority: the command of the military forces, the administration of the revenue, the appointment of provincial governors and senior officials, the diplomatic relations with foreign powers, and the day-to-day operation of the state. The amir's authority extended over the central provinces of the caliphate — Iraq, Fars, Jibal, Khuzestan, Kerman — but did not extend over the further peripheral provinces (Khurasan was under the Samanids, Egypt was under the Fatimids from 969, the western provinces of the Maghreb were independent of either party).

Buyid-period silk depicting horsemen.
Buyid PersiaA Buyid-period silk showing mounted horsemen; the Daylamite dynasty patronised a flowering of Persian art and letters.

The Shia paradox

The Buyid amirs were Shia Muslims (predominantly of the Zaydi or Imami persuasions; the Imami "Twelver" Shia tradition that would crystallise in the period was developed under Buyid sponsorship by the scholar Shaykh al-Mufid at Baghdad). The caliph was the Sunni religious sovereign. The constitutional logic of the Shia position was that the Sunni caliph was theologically illegitimate, the legitimate imam being the hidden Twelfth Imam in occultation. The constitutional logic of the Sunni position was that the Shia military overlords were theologically dissident, but acceptable as administrators of the practical functions of government.

Both parties found that the constitutional fiction was operationally useful. The Buyid amirs derived legitimating authority from being formal protectors of the recognised caliph, which the Shia population accepted on the practical ground that the Buyids were Shia in person even if Sunni in formal title. The Sunni religious establishment derived continued institutional existence from the formal protection of the caliphate. The practical political consequence — including the public celebrations of Shia religious holidays at Baghdad (the Ashura mourning, the Eid al-Ghadir celebration) that the Buyids introduced from 962, the expansion of Shia shrines at Najaf and Karbala, and the development of Shia religious scholarship — produced the formal institutional consolidation of the Twelver Shia tradition under Buyid patronage.

The cultural high point

The Buyid period was the cultural and intellectual high water mark of the tenth-century Islamic world. The major figures of the period in literature, science and philosophy were active in territories under Buyid patronage: Ibn Sina (Avicenna, 980–1037, the major philosopher and physician); al-Mutanabbi (the principal Arab poet of the period); al-Tabari (the historian, active under late Buyid patronage); al-Mas'udi (the historian and geographer); al-Biruni (the polymath, active partly under Buyid and partly under Ghaznavid patronage); the Brethren of Purity (the philosophical school that produced the encyclopedic Rasa'il); Abu al-Faraj al-Isfahani (the literary scholar of the Book of Songs). The Buyid amirs themselves were patrons of learning; Adud al-Dawla (the great Buyid amir of the late tenth century, who reunited the Buyid family realm) expanded the libraries and educational institutions at Shiraz and Baghdad.

The decline

The Buyid family's difficulty was the absence of a stable succession arrangement. The original Buyid territorial division — Iraq under one brother, Fars under another, Jibal under a third — produced a sequence of family conflicts in the second and third generations, with the parts of the family realm fighting one another and dissipating the resources of the dynasty. By the early eleventh century the Buyids were weakened by a sequence of military defeats, financial crises, and Turkish nomadic incursions into their territory.

The Seljuk Turks, who had emerged as a political force in Khurasan in the 1030s, progressively moved west through Iran in the 1040s. The Seljuk leader Tughril Beg entered Baghdad on the 18th of December 1055 unopposed by the remaining Buyid forces. The caliph al-Qa'im received Tughril Beg in formal audience, conferred upon him the title of sultan ("authority"), and the constitutional position of the caliphate shifted again — from the Shia Daylamite amirate to the Sunni Turkish sultanate that is the subject of the next chapter.

A century of Shia rule over a Sunni caliph

In December 945 Ahmad ibn Buya entered Baghdad, took the title amir al-umara, and blinded the caliph al-Mustakfi for good measure. The Buyids were Daylamite mountaineers from the Caspian, they were Zaydi or Twelver Shia, and they ruled Iraq and western Iran for a hundred and ten years while keeping a Sunni Abbasid on the throne.

The arrangement is one of the stranger constitutional devices in medieval history. The Buyids did not need the caliph's religious authority, which they did not accept, and they could have abolished the office. They kept it because it legitimised their rule to the Sunni majority they governed, and because a caliph who owed his position entirely to them was more useful than an empty throne.

The caliph in this period had a palace, a household, an allowance and no power whatever. He signed the documents put in front of him. Several were deposed and blinded; al-Ta'i was pulled off the throne in 991 and made to sign his own abdication.

Yet the tenth century under the Buyids was one of the most creative periods in Islamic intellectual history — the age of al-Farabi, Ibn Sina's teachers, the Brethren of Purity, al-Mutanabbi and the great compilers. Public Shia mourning for Husayn was permitted in Baghdad for the first time, and the shrines at Najaf and Karbala were rebuilt. The state was weak and the civilisation was not, which is a pattern worth noticing.


End of Chapter VI