Mythbusters

Ten things
people get wrong
about the Abbasids.

The golden age is real and is routinely described in terms that would embarrass the people who made it. So is the fall, which took considerably longer than the version everybody knows.

13 min read

The House of Wisdom was a great library building in Baghdad.

Mostly false

The Bayt al-Hikma is named in the sources, but what it was is much less clear than the popular account suggests. The references are scattered, mostly later, and describe something closer to a palace library and translation bureau under the caliph's patronage than an institution with a campus.

No building has been identified, no floor plan exists, and the idea of a great research academy with lecture halls and an observatory attached is largely a construction of nineteenth- and twentieth-century writing, elaborated further in popular history since the 1990s.

What is beyond doubt is the translation movement itself. Over roughly two centuries, most of the surviving Greek corpus in medicine, mathematics, astronomy and philosophy was rendered into Arabic, funded by caliphs, viziers and wealthy families, and paid extremely well — Hunayn ibn Ishaq was reportedly paid the weight of each finished book in gold. The programme was real. The building may not have been.

The Mongols ended Islamic science in 1258.

False

The sack of Baghdad in February 1258 was catastrophic, and the story of the Tigris running black with the ink of books is repeated in almost every account. It is also a literary topos — the same image is used of other cities — and the death toll of 800,000 or two million given by later writers is not credible.

More to the point, the science continued, and some of the best of it came immediately afterwards under Mongol patronage. Nasir al-Din al-Tusi, who was with Hülegü at Baghdad, persuaded him to fund an observatory at Maragha in Azerbaijan, which produced the most accurate planetary tables of the age and the mathematical devices — the Tusi couple among them — that reappear in Copernicus three centuries later.

Ibn al-Shatir at Damascus in the fourteenth century produced a planetary model mathematically identical to the Copernican one. The idea that intellectual life stopped in 1258 is a Baghdad-centred view of a very large world.

The caliph ruled the Muslim world like a pope.

False

He was neither an infallible teacher nor the head of a clergy, because Sunni Islam has no clergy and no magisterium. Doctrine was made by scholars — the ulama — whose authority came from learning and from the recognition of their peers, not from appointment.

Al-Ma'mun tried to change this. From 833 he imposed the mihna, a doctrinal test requiring officials and judges to affirm that the Qur'an was created rather than eternal, and imprisoned those who refused. Ahmad ibn Hanbal refused, was flogged and became a hero. The policy was abandoned within about fifteen years, and its failure settled the question permanently: the caliph could not define belief.

What the caliph did hold was political sovereignty in theory and the right to have his name read in the Friday prayer and struck on the coinage. By the tenth century that was very often all he held.

The golden age ended when the Mongols arrived.

False

Effective Abbasid power ended more than three centuries earlier, and the caliphate spent most of its five hundred years as a ceremonial institution.

The turning point is usually put at 861, when the caliph al-Mutawakkil was murdered by his own Turkish guard. In the nine years that followed, four caliphs were installed and disposed of by the soldiery. In 945 the Buyids — Shia Persians — took Baghdad and ruled it, keeping the Sunni caliph as a figurehead who signed what he was given. The Seljuks replaced them in 1055 on the same terms.

There was a genuine Abbasid revival in the twelfth century under al-Nasir, who ruled independently for forty-six years and rebuilt real authority in Iraq. That is what the Mongols destroyed in 1258 — not a five-century golden age but a partial recovery about seventy years old.

Baghdad was the first city of a million people.

Mostly false

The figure appears constantly and rests on nothing solid. Medieval writers give numbers for baths, mosques and physicians, and modern authors have multiplied those by assumed household sizes to reach anything between 300,000 and two million.

The most careful estimates put ninth-century Baghdad somewhere between 300,000 and 500,000 — which would still make it the largest city in the world at the time, and larger than anything in Europe by an order of magnitude, Constantinople included.

Rome under the empire had probably reached a million, eight centuries earlier, and Chang'an under the Tang may have been comparable to Baghdad or larger. The claim as usually stated is both unprovable and unnecessary: what Baghdad was is remarkable enough without it.

The Abbasids were an Arab dynasty ruling an Arab empire.

Mostly false

The family was Arab — descended from the Prophet's uncle al-Abbas, which is where their legitimacy came from — but the revolution that put them in power was made in Khorasan by a coalition in which Persian converts were decisive, and the state they built was Persian in almost every institutional respect.

The office of vizier is Sasanian. The court ceremonial, the screened and inaccessible ruler, the administrative vocabulary and the tax system are Sasanian. The Barmakids who ran the state under Harun al-Rashid were a Persian family from Balkh, formerly Buddhist. The move from Damascus to Iraq was itself a move into the Persian world.

Arabic remained the language of religion, law and science, and it is the reason the culture is often called Arab. But by the tenth century Persian was again a literary language, and the caliphate's soldiers were increasingly Turkish. Calling it an Arab empire describes its first century and not its last four.

Islam forbade images, so there is no Abbasid figurative art.

False

There is a real prohibition in the hadith tradition on images of living beings, and it was taken seriously in religious contexts: mosques are decorated with geometry, vegetal ornament and calligraphy, and there are no figures.

Secular art is a different matter entirely. The Samarra palaces were painted with dancing girls, hunters and animals; the excavated frescoes are in Berlin and Istanbul. Lustre pottery from Iraq shows human figures constantly. The Baghdad school of manuscript painting in the thirteenth century produced the illustrated Maqamat of al-Hariri, which is full of crowds, camels, ships and drinking parties, and which is one of the great achievements of medieval painting.

The distinction is between sacred and secular space, not between permitted and forbidden art, and it was drawn differently in different centuries and places.

Harun al-Rashid was the wise caliph of the <em>Arabian Nights</em>.

Partly true, but more complicated than that

He was a real caliph who reigned from 786 to 809, at the height of Abbasid wealth, and he does appear in the Thousand and One Nights wandering Baghdad in disguise to see how his people live.

The stories were written down between the ninth and fourteenth centuries, mostly long after him, and the Baghdad they describe is a literary invention. The historical Harun spent much of his reign at Raqqa rather than Baghdad, destroyed the Barmakid family who had governed for him — Ja'far, his closest companion, was executed and displayed on a bridge — and divided the empire between two sons in a way that produced a four-year civil war and the siege of his own capital.

He also exchanged embassies with Charlemagne and sent him an elephant called Abul-Abbas, which walked from Baghdad to Aachen and lived there for eight years. That part is true.

There was one caliphate.

False

From 929 there were three at once, each claiming universal authority over all Muslims.

The Abbasids held Baghdad. The Fatimids, an Ismaili Shia dynasty, took Ifriqiya in 909 and Egypt in 969, founded Cairo, and claimed the caliphate as descendants of the Prophet's daughter. Abd al-Rahman III in Córdoba declared himself caliph in 929, largely in response to the Fatimids.

They fought each other by proxy, competed for the loyalty of the holy cities and for recognition in the Friday prayer across the Islamic world, and each maintained that the others were usurpers. The Abbasids outlasted both.

The number three is itself a simplification: at various points the Almohads, the Hafsids and others claimed the title, and after 1258 a surviving Abbasid line was maintained in Cairo by the Mamluks as a source of legitimacy until the Ottomans took it in 1517.

The Abbasids were destroyed in 1258 and that was the end.

Mostly false

Hülegü had al-Musta'sim rolled in a carpet and trampled by horses, on the 20th of February 1258, so as to avoid spilling royal blood on the ground. The Baghdad caliphate ended there.

But an uncle of the dead caliph reached Cairo in 1261, and the Mamluk sultan Baybars had him installed as caliph — a purely ceremonial office, with no territory and no army, whose function was to confer legitimacy on Mamluk rule. That shadow caliphate continued in Cairo for two hundred and fifty-six years, through seventeen more Abbasids.

When Selim I conquered Egypt in 1517 the last of them, al-Mutawakkil III, was taken to Constantinople. The Ottoman claim to the caliphate, which mattered enormously in the nineteenth century and was abolished by the Turkish Grand National Assembly on the 3rd of March 1924, descends from that transfer.

Arabic numerals were an Arab invention.

Mostly false

The digits and the place-value system with a zero were developed in India, and the Arabic name for the discipline says so: hisab al-hind, Indian reckoning.

What the Abbasids did was transmit and extend it. An Indian astronomical text reached al-Mansur's court in the 770s and was translated; al-Khwarizmi wrote a book on Indian calculation in the 820s that explained the system, and a Latin translation of it in the twelfth century — beginning Dixit Algorizmi, thus said al-Khwarizmi — is how the numerals entered Europe.

They were resisted there for three centuries. Florence banned them for accounting in 1299 on the grounds that a nine could too easily be altered into a nought, and Roman numerals remained standard in European bookkeeping into the sixteenth century.

The caliphate was uniformly tolerant of Jews and Christians.

Partly true, but more complicated than that

Non-Muslim monotheists held the status of dhimmi: protected, permitted their own law and worship, and liable to a poll tax, the jizya, that Muslims did not pay. Compared with contemporary Latin Christendom, which expelled and massacred its Jewish communities repeatedly, this was a considerably better arrangement, and Jewish and Christian communities under Abbasid rule produced philosophy, medicine and commerce at a very high level.

It was not equality, and it was not stable. The Pact of Umar, elaborated over the ninth century, prescribed distinctive dress, prohibitions on new church building and on riding horses, and a general requirement of visible deference. Enforcement varied enormously with the caliph and the decade: al-Mutawakkil enforced the sumptuary rules harshly from 850, and the Fatimid caliph al-Hakim destroyed the Church of the Holy Sepulchre in 1009.

The honest summary is a legally subordinate status, applied with a mildness that fluctuated, under which minority communities could and did flourish — and which nobody living under it would have mistaken for tolerance in the modern sense.

Islamic law was fixed and unchanging.

False

The four surviving Sunni schools of law — Hanafi, Maliki, Shafi'i and Hanbali — all took their classical shape under the Abbasids, in the eighth and ninth centuries, and their existence is itself the answer. Four schools means four defensible readings of the same sources, all regarded as orthodox, all with different rules on inheritance, contract and marriage.

The mechanism of change was the fatwa and the jurist who issued it. New situations — paper money, coffee, tobacco, new commercial instruments — were argued out by scholars applying analogy and public interest, and the answers differed by school, by region and by century.

The idea that the gate of independent reasoning closed around 900 was a claim made by some later jurists and repeated confidently by nineteenth-century orientalists. Wael Hallaq's work has shown it to be false as a description of what jurists actually did: they went on reasoning, and said so.

The caliphate collapsed because of religious conservatism.

False

The story runs that a rationalist golden age was strangled by orthodoxy — usually dated to al-Ghazali's Incoherence of the Philosophers around 1095, which is said to have killed philosophy and with it science.

It does not fit the chronology. Al-Ghazali attacked specific metaphysical claims of the Aristotelians, not natural science, and he was himself a considerable logician who insisted logic was neutral. Ibn Rushd answered him at length. The most productive centuries of Islamic astronomy came after him: the Maragha observatory in the 1260s, Ibn al-Shatir in the 1350s, Ulugh Beg's tables at Samarkand in the 1430s.

What actually broke the caliphate was political and fiscal. The Turkish guard captured the state in 861. The iqta system, which paid soldiers by assigning them tax revenues, hollowed out the treasury over two centuries. The Zanj revolt and the Qarmatian raids wrecked southern Iraq's agriculture, and the canal system that had made Mesopotamia rich since Sumer was never fully repaired. Money and soldiers, not theology.

Baghdad's libraries were the largest in the world.

Partly true, but more complicated than that

They were certainly among the largest, and the figures given for them — 400,000 volumes at Córdoba, comparable numbers in Baghdad, Cairo and Shiraz — dwarf anything in Latin Europe, where a great monastic library held a few hundred codices.

But the comparison flatters Baghdad by ignoring China. The Song imperial library was of a similar order, and Chinese printing from the tenth century meant that books were being produced in quantities no manuscript culture could approach.

The Abbasid achievement was not the size of any one collection but the density of them: a working bookseller's market on the Suq al-Warraqin, private libraries in scholars' houses, endowed libraries attached to mosques and hospitals with reading rooms, paid copyists and lending. Ibn Sina described the Samanid library at Bukhara as having a separate room for each subject. That is an infrastructure, not a hoard.