Chapter VI  ·  1648 – 1700

Westphalia,
Federal Empire.

The post-war settlement and the empire as a multi-confessional federation of effectively sovereign princes.

Gerard ter Borch's painting of the Peace of Westphalia, 1648.
The Peace of Westphalia, 1648Gerard ter Borch's eyewitness painting of the ratification of the Treaty of Münster, 15 May 1648 — the settlement that recast the empire as a multi-confessional federation.

10 min read

The fifty-two years between the Peace of Westphalia and the close of the seventeenth century were the empire's period of institutional consolidation. The constitutional architecture of the post-1648 settlement had to be made operational, and the substance of what the empire would now be — a multi-confessional federation rather than a confessional polity, a permanently negotiated political space rather than a hierarchical state, a defensive bloc against external threats rather than an offensive power — had to be tested in practice. The principal external threat of the period was Ottoman, and the principal internal institutional development was the conversion of the imperial diet from an intermittently summoned assembly into the Permanent Diet (Immerwährender Reichstag) at Regensburg, sitting continuously from 1663 onward and surviving until the empire's dissolution.

The Permanent Diet

The Permanent Diet at Regensburg, opened in 1663, was a structural innovation forced on the empire by the difficulty of summoning periodic diets for legislation, taxation, and treaty ratification under the Westphalian constitution. Each imperial estate sent permanent envoys (Reichstagsgesandte) to Regensburg; the envoys were organised in three colleges — the electors, the princes, and the imperial cities — voting in their respective chambers. Joint resolutions of the three colleges, ratified by the emperor, became Reichsgutachten with the force of imperial law. The diet sat in the Regensburg town hall, in chambers (still visible to visitors today) preserved largely unchanged. It was not a legislature in the modern sense — its consents were generally to imperial proposals rather than its own initiatives — but it was the principal mechanism by which the imperial estates kept the emperor's authority under collective check.

The Reichssaal of the Perpetual Diet at Regensburg.
The Reichssaal at RegensburgThe chamber of the Perpetual Diet, which sat continuously from 1663 until the empire's dissolution, preserved largely unchanged.

The decisional difficulty was substantial. Many resolutions required unanimity within each college; some required unanimity across colleges; the religious-confessional balance was preserved by the institution of the itio in partes — the right of either confessional party (Catholic or Protestant) to demand that a question be voted in separate confessional chambers rather than by majority of the whole — which gave each confession an absolute veto on religious matters. The combination produced an institutional bias toward stasis: the diet was good at preventing change and weak at producing it. For most of the eighteenth century this was, in fact, what its members preferred.

The Ottoman wars

The external history of the empire in the late seventeenth century was dominated by the renewed Ottoman pressure on the Habsburg eastern frontier. After fifty years of relative quiet (the long Habsburg-Ottoman peace of 1606–1660 broken only by minor frontier skirmishes), the Ottomans under the Köprülü viziers resumed major offensive operations: the Hungarian war of 1663–1664 (defeated by Habsburg-French forces at Saint-Gotthard on the Rába river), the Polish-Ottoman war of the 1670s, and the great offensive of 1683 that brought the Grand Vizier Kara Mustafa to the walls of Vienna in July of that year. The siege of Vienna ran from the 14th of July to the 12th of September 1683. The defence was conducted by Count Rüdiger Starhemberg with a garrison of 11,000 against an Ottoman army of approximately 150,000; relief was delivered by the Polish king Jan III Sobieski, the Lorrainer Charles V, and the Saxon and Bavarian electors at the Battle of Kahlenberg on the 12th of September. The Ottoman army was routed; Kara Mustafa was strangled by the Sultan's order at Belgrade three months later.

The Vienna relief opened a fifteen-year Habsburg counteroffensive — the Great Turkish War of 1683–1699 — which reconquered Hungary, Transylvania, Slavonia and parts of Serbia under the brilliant general Eugene of Savoy, whose victory at Zenta in 1697 broke the Ottoman field army. The Peace of Karlowitz of 1699 transferred the recovered territories to the Habsburg crown, doubling the size of the hereditary lands and converting Vienna from a frontier garrison into the operational capital of a Danubian empire. The empire as such, however, gained no territory; the Habsburg dynastic gains were juridically external to the imperial structure, even though the army that achieved them had been mobilised through the imperial defensive levy.

The Louis XIV wars

The empire's western front in the late seventeenth century was the contest with the France of Louis XIV. The War of Devolution (1667–1668), the Franco-Dutch War (1672–1678), the Reunion policy of 1680–1688 (a programme of legal annexations by French chambres de réunion of imperial territory in the Saar and Alsace), the Nine Years' War (1688–1697), and the War of the Spanish Succession (1701–1714) were a continuous strategic engagement between Louis's France and the empire-plus-allied-coalition (the Dutch, England under William III and Anne, and the maritime powers generally) for control of the Spanish inheritance and for the western imperial frontier. The empire as institution played a defensive role — the imperial military constitution (Reichskriegsverfassung) of 1681 organised imperial contingents from the various Circles for defensive operations — while the principal military weight was carried by the Habsburg hereditary army and its allies. The territorial outcome was the loss of imperial territory in Alsace (formally ceded at Westphalia and progressively extended through the Reunion policy) and the institutional retreat of the imperial frontier to the Rhine.

The princely territorial state

The most consequential internal development of the period was the consolidation of the great territorial principalities — Brandenburg-Prussia under the Great Elector Frederick William (1640–1688), Bavaria under Maximilian II Emanuel, Saxony under the Albertine Wettins, Hanover under Ernest Augustus (whose son George would become George I of Great Britain in 1714) — into regional powers with standing armies, professional bureaucracies, and territorial-economic policies in the cameralist mode. The Brandenburg-Prussian case is particularly important: the Great Elector's military and administrative reforms after 1648 produced, over two generations, the most professionalised army in the empire and the foundations of what would become, in 1701, the Kingdom of Prussia. The kingdom-of-Prussia question is the subject of Volume I in this library; for the present chapter the point is that the empire's federal structure was now containing a major rival to Habsburg authority within itself, the long-term consequence of the Westphalian transfer of substantive sovereignty to the territorial princes.

The eighteenth-century inheritance

By 1700 the institutional outlines of the post-Westphalian empire were settled. The Habsburgs held the imperial title and were consolidating a major Danubian state. The Bourbons in France were the empire's principal external rival. Brandenburg-Prussia was rising. The imperial diet at Regensburg was the empire's permanent constitutional theatre. The imperial courts at Wetzlar (the Reichskammergericht) and Vienna (the Reichshofrat) provided judicial review. The Aulic Council adjudicated feudal-imperial questions. The system functioned, slowly and defensively, for the next hundred years. The eighteenth century is the next chapter.

The courts that replaced the wars

The settlement of 1648 is usually described in terms of what the princes gained. It is at least as important for what it left standing: two supreme courts, both of which went on working for another century and a half, and which are the reason the Empire could function without an army.

The Imperial Chamber Court — the Reichskammergericht — had been founded in 1495 as the price the princes paid for the abolition of private war. It sat at Speyer until the French sacked the city in 1689, and then at Wetzlar until the end. Its judges were nominated by the estates rather than the emperor, which made it the estates' own instrument, and its jurisdiction covered disputes between imperial estates and, remarkably, suits brought by subjects against their own rulers.

Against it stood the Aulic Council in Vienna, the Reichshofrat, which was the emperor's personal court and answered to him alone. Litigants chose between the two, and the choice was political: a Protestant estate suing a Catholic neighbour went to Wetzlar, and a small territory hoping for imperial protection against a large one went to Vienna.

Both were slow. The Chamber Court's backlog reached 61,000 cases by 1772 and suits routinely outlived the parties who began them; the standing joke was that a case was inherited like a farm. But slowness was not the same as uselessness. A prince facing a suit had to answer it, and the delay itself protected the weaker party, because it froze the position while the matter was pending.

The volume of business is the real evidence. Something in the order of 80,000 cases went to Wetzlar and a similar number to Vienna, and a very large proportion came from below — villages against their lords over grazing rights, guilds against town councils, subjects against taxes they said were unlawful. It is the largest surviving record of ordinary Europeans arguing with authority, and it exists because the Empire gave them somewhere to argue.


End of Chapter VI