Mythbusters

Ten things
people get wrong
about South Vietnam.

A war remembered mostly through American films, in which the country the war was fought over is usually scenery. These are corrections about the Republic itself.

13 min read

South Vietnam was an American invention.

Partly true, but more complicated than that

The Republic could not have survived without American money and it is fair to call it a client state. But it was not conjured out of nothing.

The State of Vietnam existed from 1949 under Bảo Đại, within the French Union, before the Americans were significantly involved. The partition at the seventeenth parallel was a French and Viet Minh arrangement made at Geneva in 1954, over Vietnamese objections on both sides. And around 900,000 people, the great majority Catholics from the North, moved south in 1954–55 — a population with its own reasons for not wanting a communist state, which became the Republic's political core.

Diệm himself was a Vietnamese nationalist with a record of refusing office from both the French and Ho Chi Minh, and Washington found him difficult from the beginning. The country was a client. It was not a fiction.

The ARVN would not fight.

False

Somewhere between 250,000 and 313,000 South Vietnamese soldiers were killed in the war — several times the American figure of 58,220, and a far higher proportion of the population.

The army's performance was extremely uneven, and the reasons were structural rather than moral: senior appointments were political, corruption in the officer corps was serious, desertion rates were high, and units were often deployed to protect a general's province rather than to fight. That is a failure of the state, and it belongs on the Republic's account.

But ARVN airborne, marine and ranger units were as good as any in the theatre. At An Lộc in 1972 an ARVN garrison held a town under siege for sixty-six days against three divisions with armour. In 1972 the Easter Offensive was stopped almost entirely by South Vietnamese ground troops with American air support. The reflexive contempt is a piece of American self-exculpation.

The war ended with the Paris accords in 1973.

False

The Paris Peace Accords of the 27th of January 1973 ended American involvement. American combat troops left within sixty days and the prisoners of war came home. Kissinger and Lê Đức Thọ were awarded the Nobel Peace Prize; Thọ declined it, on the grounds that there was no peace.

He was right. The agreement left some 150,000 North Vietnamese troops in place inside South Vietnam, which made the outcome close to inevitable, and the fighting never actually stopped. The two years that followed were among the war's bloodiest for Vietnamese on both sides.

American aid to Saigon was then cut from $2.3 billion in 1973 to $700 million in 1975, while Soviet and Chinese aid to Hanoi continued. The final offensive began in March 1975 and took fifty-five days.

The Americans lost because they were beaten in the field.

Mostly false

American forces won most of the set-piece engagements they fought, and the standard observation — attributed to Colonel Harry Summers, who put it to a North Vietnamese colonel in 1975 — is that the Americans were never defeated on the battlefield, and that this was true and irrelevant.

The war was not a contest for territory. It was a contest over whether the government in Saigon could be made legitimate and self-sustaining, and that was lost in the villages, in the corruption of the administration, and in the American domestic politics that the Tet offensive shattered — Tet being a severe military defeat for the Viet Cong, who were effectively destroyed as a fighting force, and a decisive political victory all the same.

Winning every battle while losing the war is not a paradox. It is what happens when the battles are not the point.

Ngô Đình Diệm was assassinated by the Americans.

Partly true, but more complicated than that

Diệm and his brother Nhu were killed on the 2nd of November 1963 in the back of an armoured personnel carrier, after surrendering to the generals who had overthrown them the previous day.

The coup was carried out by South Vietnamese generals. But the Kennedy administration had signalled, through Cable 243 of the 24th of August and through Ambassador Lodge's contacts with the plotters, that it would not oppose a change of government and would continue support afterwards. That is not the same as ordering the killings, which the generals appear to have decided on themselves, and Kennedy is reported to have been shaken by the news.

Three weeks later Kennedy was himself assassinated. The Republic then went through seven governments in eighteen months, and never recovered the authority Diệm had. Whatever his failings, the coup made things worse.

The domino theory was nonsense.

Partly true, but more complicated than that

The strong form of the theory — that the fall of Saigon would topple governments across Asia to the Pacific — did not happen. Thailand, Malaysia, Indonesia, the Philippines and Singapore were not overthrown; several went the other way and prospered.

The weak form did happen, and in the worst way. Laos fell to the Pathet Lao in 1975. Cambodia fell to the Khmer Rouge in April 1975, two weeks before Saigon, and the regime that followed killed around 1.7 million people — roughly a quarter of the population — before Vietnam invaded in 1978 and removed it.

That invasion then produced a Chinese punitive war against Vietnam in 1979. The region was destabilised for another fifteen years. Whether that vindicates the theory or indicts the war that helped produce the conditions is a judgement, and honest people make it both ways.

Agent Orange was just a defoliant.

False

Around 76 million litres of herbicide were sprayed over southern Vietnam between 1961 and 1971 under Operation Ranch Hand, of which about 45 million litres were Agent Orange. The purpose was to strip jungle cover and destroy crops, and roughly a fifth of South Vietnam's forests were sprayed at least once.

The problem is the contaminant. The manufacturing process left TCDD, one of the most toxic dioxins known, in the mixture, and it persists in soil and enters the food chain. The US Department of Veterans Affairs now presumes a service connection for a list of conditions including several cancers, Parkinson's disease and type 2 diabetes.

Vietnam claims three million people affected and around 150,000 children born with related defects; American courts have not accepted Vietnamese claims, while settling with US veterans. Hotspot remediation at Đà Nẵng and Biên Hòa, funded by the United States, has been under way since 2012 and is expected to run into the 2030s.

Everyone in the South supported the communists.

False

Around 900,000 people moved south in 1954–55 rather than live under the Democratic Republic, against perhaps 130,000 moving north. That is a verdict delivered with people's feet.

After 1975 the movement continued in the same direction under far worse conditions. Between 1975 and 1995 something like 800,000 people left Vietnam by sea in small boats; the UNHCR's estimate of those who died at sea runs from 200,000 to 400,000. Something like a million people passed through re-education camps, some for a decade.

Equally, the Republic never commanded the loyalty of the peasantry it needed, and the National Liberation Front had genuine popular support in much of the countryside. Both things are true, which is what makes it a civil war rather than an invasion.

The Republic simply collapsed in 1975.

Mostly false

The final campaign lasted fifty-five days and the collapse, when it came, was very fast — but it had a specific cause, and it was a decision rather than a rout.

In March 1975, after losing Ban Mê Thuột, President Thiệu ordered a withdrawal from the Central Highlands to shorten the line. The order was given without adequate planning, the withdrawal route was a disused road, and the retreating columns were joined by hundreds of thousands of civilians. The Convoy of Tears disintegrated under artillery fire, and with it the II Corps.

That single operational decision unravelled the north of the country in a fortnight. Huế fell on the 25th of March, Đà Nẵng on the 30th. The army that had stopped the 1972 offensive was destroyed by its own retreat, not by being beaten in position.

Vietnam is still hostile to Americans.

False

Vietnam is among the most pro-American populations in the world by survey, consistently above eighty per cent favourable, and the median Vietnamese was born long after 1975. The war is called the American War, is taught as one episode in two thousand years of resisting outside powers, and is not a live grievance.

The United States and Vietnam normalised relations in 1995, and upgraded to a comprehensive strategic partnership in 2023 — the highest tier Vietnam offers, which it also extends to China and Russia. American warships call at Đà Nẵng.

The reason is straightforward and has nothing to do with forgiveness: Vietnam has fought China repeatedly, most recently in 1979 and at sea since, and is engaged in a maritime dispute with it now. Travellers should expect friendliness and should not expect the war to be a delicate subject; it will be raised before you raise it.