The Travel Guide

The places
of the Confederacy.

Twenty-six stops across eleven states. The battlefields are the best-preserved in the world and the easiest part of the trip; the harder and more necessary half is the ground where the four million people the war was fought over actually lived.

The National Park Service runs most of it and runs it well. Two weeks covers the east; the west and the Deep South are separate journeys.

Richmond, the capital

The Confederate government moved here from Montgomery in May 1861, largely to keep Virginia in the new country, and the decision put the capital a hundred miles from Washington and made the state a battleground for four years. The city has spent the last decade rearranging what it says about all this, and is the single most interesting place in the volume for that reason.

i.

Richmond · Virginia

Tredegar Iron Works

The Tredegar Iron Works on the James River at Richmond.
TredegarThe foundry that made roughly half the Confederacy's domestically produced artillery, and the reason the capital moved to Richmond.

The largest ironworks in the South, on the James River at the falls, and the practical reason Richmond was worth defending. Tredegar cast something like half of all the artillery the Confederacy manufactured for itself, rolled armour plate for the ironclads, and at its peak employed around 2,500 people — a proportion of them enslaved, hired out by their owners to the company by the year.

That last fact is the one to hold on to. The Confederate war effort was not merely defending slavery as a matter of principle; it ran on enslaved labour directly, in the foundries, on the fortifications, in the army's supply trains and in the fields that fed it. When the enslaved population began withdrawing that labour — by leaving for Union lines, and eventually by enlisting — the war economy lost its footing.

The ruin of the gun foundry now houses the main site of the American Civil War Museum, which since 2019 has told the war from Union, Confederate and African American perspectives in the same building. It is the best single introduction to the subject anywhere, and it is the right place to begin.

Time: Half a day · Best for: Why the war lasted four years · Note: Home of the American Civil War Museum
ii.

Richmond · Virginia

The White House of the Confederacy

The White House of the Confederacy, Richmond, Virginia.
1201 East Clay StreetJefferson Davis's executive mansion, August 1861 to April 1865, restored to its wartime appearance.

A grey stuccoed neoclassical house of 1818, rented for the Confederate president by the city of Richmond, and the place to understand that the Confederacy was an actual functioning state rather than an abstraction: a cabinet, a treasury printing unbacked paper, a conscription bureau, a postal service that ran at a profit because rates were set high enough, and a president who was a competent administrator and an impossible colleague.

The interior has been restored to the 1860s with an unusual proportion of original furnishings, and the guided tour is unsentimental about who kept the house running. The Davises' household staff were enslaved, several of them escaped during the war, and the guides say so.

Richmond was also full of Unionists. Elizabeth Van Lew, a wealthy abolitionist who lived on Church Hill, ran the most productive Union intelligence network in the Confederacy for most of the war and was never caught. The much-repeated story that she placed an agent named Mary Bowser as a servant inside this house rests on testimony recorded decades later and cannot be verified; the network itself is documented beyond argument.

Time: 90 minutes · Best for: The government as a government · Ticket: Combined with the museum at Tredegar
iii.

Richmond · Virginia

Shockoe Bottom and Lumpkin's Jail

In the decades before the war Richmond was the second-largest market in enslaved human beings in the United States, after New Orleans, and the largest source of people sold into the Deep South. The business was concentrated in a few blocks of Shockoe Bottom, below Capitol Hill, and by the late 1850s it was turning over something in the order of $4 million a year.

Robert Lumpkin's jail — a holding compound for people awaiting sale, known locally as the Devil's Half Acre — was excavated in 2008 beneath a car park and a railway embankment. Standing there is a strange and unresolved experience, because there is very little to see: the site has been the subject of a long argument about memorialisation, a baseball stadium was once proposed for part of it, and a museum has been planned for years.

Go anyway, with the Richmond Slave Trail and the Reconciliation Statue at the foot of it, and then walk up the hill to the Capitol. The distance between the two is about half a mile, and the relationship between them is the subject of this volume.

Time: Two hours · Best for: The trade the war protected · Note: Interpretation is sparse; read first
iv.

Richmond · Virginia

Hollywood Cemetery

Hollywood Cemetery, Richmond, Virginia.
HollywoodEighteen thousand Confederate dead, a ninety-foot granite pyramid of 1869, and the beginnings of the Lost Cause.

A rolling garden cemetery above the James rapids, holding Jefferson Davis, J. E. B. Stuart, George Pickett, two presidents of the United States — Monroe and Tyler — and roughly eighteen thousand Confederate soldiers, including some two thousand eight hundred brought back from Gettysburg in the early 1870s.

That reinterment campaign is the thing to notice. It was organised by the Hollywood Memorial Association, one of the Ladies' Memorial Associations that sprang up across the South after 1865, and it was the machinery through which the Lost Cause was assembled: grief first, then commemoration, then a historical argument that grew out of the commemoration and eventually replaced it.

The ninety-foot dry-laid granite pyramid of 1869 stands over the soldiers' section. It was built by public subscription at a moment when Richmond could barely feed itself, which tells you how much the project mattered to the people who paid for it.

Time: Two hours · Best for: How the myth was built · Note: Free; steep paths above the James
v.

Richmond · Virginia

Monument Avenue

The Robert E. Lee statue on Monument Avenue, Richmond, before its removal.
Lee on Monument AvenueUnveiled in 1890, removed in September 2021, its pedestal taken down in December 2022. The boulevard was laid out around it.

A grand tree-lined boulevard laid out from 1890 around an equestrian Lee, and then developed as high-status residential property precisely because the statues were there. Jackson, Stuart, Davis and Matthew Fontaine Maury followed between 1907 and 1929. Arthur Ashe, the Richmond-born tennis champion who grew up unable to play on the city's white courts, was added in 1996 after a bitter fight.

Most of it is gone. The city removed Jackson, Stuart, Davis and Maury in July 2020; the state removed Lee — the largest of them — in September 2021, and took down the pedestal, which had become a canvas of protest photography, in December 2022. Ashe remains.

Walk it and look at the dates on what is left of the bases. These were not put up by mourning veterans in 1866. They went up between 1890 and 1930, as the southern states were writing black voters out of the electorate, and the avenue was in that sense a statement about the present when it was built — which is what its defenders and its critics have always agreed on, while disagreeing about everything else.

Time: An hour's walk · Best for: The present tense · Note: The Lee pedestal was removed in December 2022

The eastern armies

Four years of fighting in a corridor a hundred miles long produced the most intensively preserved battlefields on earth. The Park Service sites are excellent and the private preservation trusts have bought up a great deal of the rest; what this means in practice is that you can stand where a line stood and see roughly what it saw.

vi.

Manassas · Virginia

Manassas National Battlefield Park

The Stone House at Manassas National Battlefield Park, Virginia.
The Stone HouseA turnpike inn that served as a field hospital in both battles, and the landmark every account of the ground is oriented by.

Two battles on the same ground, thirteen months apart. First Manassas on the 21st of July 1861 was the engagement that ended the expectation of a ninety-day war: a confused, amateur collision of two half-trained armies that the Confederates won when reinforcements arrived by rail from the Shenandoah, and that produced the rout of the Union army back towards Washington along roads clogged with civilian spectators.

It also produced the war's most durable nickname, when Barnard Bee is supposed to have said that Jackson was standing like a stone wall. Bee was killed within the hour and there is a long-running dispute about whether he meant it as praise or as a complaint that Jackson would not move.

Second Manassas, in August 1862, was a much larger and more professional battle and a far worse Union defeat, and it opened the road to Lee's first invasion of the North. Henry Hill is the place to stand for the first battle; the unfinished railroad cut, where Jackson's men ran out of ammunition and threw rocks, is the place for the second.

Time: Half a day · Best for: The illusion of a short war · Combine with: Washington, 30 miles east
vii.

Fredericksburg · Virginia

Fredericksburg and Spotsylvania

The sunken road and stone wall at Marye's Heights, Fredericksburg.
Marye's HeightsThe stone wall and the sunken road. Fourteen Union assaults crossed the open ground below it on the 13th of December 1862; none reached it.

The densest concentration of killing ground in North America: Fredericksburg, Chancellorsville, the Wilderness and Spotsylvania Court House, fought over the same twenty-mile stretch between December 1862 and May 1864, with something over 100,000 casualties between them.

At Fredericksburg, Burnside sent wave after wave across open ground at a sunken road behind a stone wall and lost nearly 13,000 men to fewer than 5,000. At Chancellorsville, five months later, Lee divided a smaller army in the face of a larger one and won his most admired victory — and lost Jackson to his own pickets in the dark, which is commemorated by a small monument at the spot.

Then the character of the war changes. At the Wilderness and Spotsylvania in May 1864, Grant took comparable losses and did not withdraw, which no previous commander in the theatre had done. The Bloody Angle at Spotsylvania — where the lines fought hand to hand across a parapet for close to twenty hours in the rain, and an oak tree twenty-two inches thick was cut down by rifle fire — is the place where the last illusions about this war go.

Time: A full day, better two · Best for: Four battles in twenty miles · Note: One park, four separate sites
viii.

Sharpsburg · Maryland

Antietam National Battlefield

Antietam National Battlefield, Sharpsburg, Maryland.

The 17th of September 1862: around 22,700 men killed, wounded or missing in twelve hours, which remains the bloodiest single day in American history. The Cornfield changed hands half a dozen times before nine in the morning. The Sunken Road, afterwards the Bloody Lane, held for three hours and then became a trap. Burnside's Bridge was carried in the afternoon, too late.

Tactically it was a draw and Lee withdrew across the Potomac unpursued. Strategically it was decisive twice over. It ended the first invasion of the North, and it gave Lincoln the victory he had been waiting for since July to issue the preliminary Emancipation Proclamation, five days later — which changed what the war was about, and with it the chances of British or French recognition.

Antietam is the least developed and least altered major battlefield of the war, kept close to its 1862 field pattern by the Park Service. Go early, and walk the Cornfield before the light gets flat.

Time: Half a day · Best for: The single bloodiest day · Note: The least altered battlefield of the war
ix.

Gettysburg · Pennsylvania

Gettysburg National Military Park

Gettysburg National Military Park, Pennsylvania.
GettysburgThree days, some 51,000 casualties, and 1,300 monuments — the most heavily memorialised ground in the country.

The 1st to 3rd of July 1863, roughly 51,000 casualties, and the northernmost point the Army of Northern Virginia ever reached. It is not quite the turning point of the war that popular memory makes it — Vicksburg fell the next day and arguably mattered more, and Lee's army fought on for twenty-one months — but it is the largest battle ever fought in the western hemisphere and it broke the offensive capacity of the Confederacy's best army for good.

The park carries about 1,300 monuments, which is itself the point: this is where both sides came to argue about what had happened, veterans' associations placing markers to fix their own regiment's version of events, well into the twentieth century. The Virginia and North Carolina memorials are Lost Cause documents in bronze; read them as such.

Hire one of the licensed battlefield guides. They sit a genuinely difficult examination, they will drive your own car, and two hours with one is worth a week of reading. Then walk the mile of open ground of Pickett's Charge from the Confederate side, which takes about twenty minutes and explains the whole thing.

Time: Two days · Best for: The war's most-visited ground · Note: Book a licensed battlefield guide

The end in Virginia

Ten months of siege lines south of Richmond, and then a week of running retreat that finished in a village parlour. The two sites are an hour apart and belong together.

x.

Petersburg · Virginia

Petersburg National Battlefield

The Crater at Petersburg National Battlefield, Virginia.
The CraterPennsylvania coal miners tunnelled under the Confederate line and fired four tons of powder on the 30th of July 1864. The assault that followed was a catastrophe.

Not a siege in the strict sense but a ten-month stalemate along thirty-odd miles of entrenchment, fought to cut the railways that fed Richmond. The earthworks, the mining, the mortars and the slow westward extension of the lines look forward to the Western Front with an exactness that is uncomfortable to stand in.

The Crater is the set piece. Miners of the 48th Pennsylvania, coal men in civilian life, dug a 511-foot gallery under the Confederate works and blew four tons of powder at dawn on the 30th of July 1864. The explosion worked. The assault did not: a division of United States Colored Troops had trained for weeks to lead it, was pulled out at the last moment on Meade's order — partly from fear of how it would look politically if they were slaughtered — and the untrained white division sent in its place went into the hole rather than around it. The Confederate counter-attack killed many of the black soldiers who came in behind them after they had surrendered.

Petersburg is under-visited compared with the battlefields an hour north, and it is the site that explains how the war actually ended.

Time: Half a day · Best for: Trench warfare, fifty years early · Combine with: Richmond, 25 miles north
xi.

Appomattox · Virginia

Appomattox Court House

The parlour of the McLean House at Appomattox Court House, photographed in 1865.
The McLean parlourPhotographed in 1865, and stripped by souvenir hunters almost immediately. The room you walk into today is a careful reconstruction of this one.

A reconstructed village, which sounds disappointing and is not. The McLean House parlour where Lee surrendered the Army of Northern Virginia to Grant on the 9th of April 1865 was dismantled by a speculator in 1893 and the Park Service rebuilt it on the original foundations; the village around it is largely original.

The terms are the reason to come. Grant let officers keep side arms and horses, paroled the men instead of imprisoning them, issued rations from Union trains, and wrote in a clause protecting the paroled from prosecution so long as they observed their parole — which Grant later invoked, successfully, against his own president's wish to try Lee for treason. It was a deliberate decision not to hang anybody, and it shaped everything that followed, for better and for worse.

Three days later Joshua Chamberlain, commanding the federal troops along the surrender road, ordered his men to present arms as the Confederate column came to stack its weapons. It is the most quoted moment of the war's ending and it is also, in a way, the first act of the reconciliation that would be purchased at the expense of the freed people.

Time: Half a day · Best for: The surrender, and the terms · Note: The McLean House is a 1940s reconstruction

Charleston, where it began

South Carolina seceded first, on the 20th of December 1860, and fired the first shot four months later. It was also, by some distance, the most thoroughly enslaved society in North America: 57 per cent of the state's population was enslaved in 1860, and in the low country parishes it was over eighty.

xii.

Charleston · South Carolina

Fort Sumter

Fort Sumter in Charleston harbour, South Carolina.
Fort SumterConfederate batteries opened fire at half past four in the morning on the 12th of April 1861. Nobody was killed in the bombardment.

A brick pentagon on an artificial island at the harbour mouth, reachable only by the park ferry, which is part of the pleasure of it. Major Robert Anderson moved his small United States garrison here from Fort Moultrie the day after Christmas 1860, and the standoff that followed ran for three and a half months while both governments worked out whether they were prepared to start a war over a fort.

The bombardment opened at 4.30 in the morning on the 12th of April 1861 and lasted thirty-four hours. Nobody was killed by it. Two Union soldiers died in an accidental explosion during the salute at the surrender ceremony, which makes them the war's first fatalities and is a detail worth carrying, given what the next four years cost.

The fort you see is not the fort of 1861. Federal artillery pounded it into a low mound during the twenty-month siege that followed, and the visible structure is largely the later rebuilding around Battery Huger of 1899. The museum is small and good, and the ferry ride across the harbour gives you the geography that made the argument unavoidable.

Time: Half a day including the ferry · Best for: The first shot · Note: Ferry from Liberty Square or Patriots Point
xiii.

Charleston · South Carolina

The Old Slave Mart

The Old Slave Mart Museum on Chalmers Street, Charleston.

A covered sales room on Chalmers Street, built in 1859 after the city banned public auctions in the open street — not from any scruple about the trade but because the spectacle had become embarrassing in front of northern and foreign visitors. Ryan's Mart handled sales until 1863.

Roughly 40 per cent of all enslaved Africans brought to what became the United States came through Charleston, most of them landed at Sullivan's Island, where they were held in quarantine sheds — a place the historian Peter Wood called the Ellis Island of black America, and which has, in proportion, almost nothing on it.

The museum is city-run, occupies one modest room, and is the only building of its kind surviving in the South as a museum. It does not editorialise; it does not need to. The bills of sale do the work.

Time: 90 minutes · Best for: The mechanics of the trade · Note: Small; go on a weekday morning
xiv.

Charleston · South Carolina

McLeod Plantation

Slave cabins at McLeod Plantation Historic Site, James Island, Charleston.
McLeodSix surviving cabins, and a site interpreted from the point of view of the people who lived in them.

A sea-island cotton plantation on James Island with six original clapboard cabins still standing along the approach, and the plantation site in the Charleston area that has most thoroughly rethought what it is for. The interpretation is built around the seventy-four people enslaved here and their descendants, rather than around the house, and the guides are direct about it.

The cabins were lived in continuously until 1990. That is the sentence that tends to stop visitors: the last residents were descendants of the people enslaved on the property, still in the same buildings, well within living memory. The site was a Freedmen's Bureau headquarters after the war and the surrounding community, the Gullah settlement of Riverland, grew from it.

If you have time for only one plantation in the Carolinas, make it this one, or Middleton Place's Eliza's House. Avoid the wedding-venue plantations; they exist in quantity and they are what McLeod was built to answer.

Time: Two hours · Best for: Sea-island cotton, and after · Note: On James Island, fifteen minutes from downtown

Montgomery and the reckoning

The Confederacy was founded in Montgomery in February 1861 and governed from there for three months. The same city produced the bus boycott of 1955, and now holds the most ambitious memorial in the United States to the violence that followed the war. The three things are within a mile of each other and should be seen on the same day.

xv.

Montgomery · Alabama

The Alabama State Capitol

The Alabama State Capitol, Montgomery.
The first capitolJefferson Davis was inaugurated on these steps on the 18th of February 1861. The Selma march ended at the same spot in 1965.

Delegates from six seceded states met here on the 4th of February 1861, wrote a provisional constitution in four days, and elected Jefferson Davis president of a country that did not yet have an army. He was inaugurated on the portico steps a fortnight later. A brass star marks the spot.

The permanent Confederate constitution, adopted in March, is the document to read. It copies the United States Constitution closely, and the changes are instructive: it names slavery explicitly where the original had used euphemism, guarantees the right of property in "negro slaves" in any territory the Confederacy might acquire, and forbids the Confederate Congress from ever passing a law impairing that right. A country founded on states' rights wrote into its constitution a rule that no state could abolish slavery.

The same steps are where the Selma to Montgomery march arrived on the 25th of March 1965, and where George Wallace had been inaugurated two years earlier promising segregation forever. The Dexter Avenue King Memorial Baptist Church is a hundred yards down the hill. Stand on the portico and look at it.

Time: Two hours with the First White House · Best for: The founding · Note: Free; closed at weekends
xvi.

Montgomery · Alabama

The First White House of the Confederacy

The First White House of the Confederacy, Montgomery, Alabama.

An 1835 Italianate house, moved in 1921 to a site opposite the Capitol, where the Davis family lived from February to May 1861 before the government left for Richmond. It is maintained by the White House Association of Alabama, founded in 1900, and it is a survival of an older kind of Confederate site.

That is the reason to go. The interpretation here is essentially unchanged from the Lost Cause tradition that built it — reverent about Davis, silent about the household's enslaved staff, and organised around relics. Coming to it directly from the Legacy Museum, a fifteen-minute walk away, is the sharpest single juxtaposition available anywhere in this volume.

It is not presented here as a thing to be indignant about. It is a document of how the war was remembered for a century, preserved in its own terms, and it is genuinely useful to see one of those intact.

Time: An hour · Best for: Contrast · Note: Run by a private association, not the state
xvii.

Montgomery · Alabama

The Legacy Museum and the National Memorial for Peace and Justice

Kwame Akoto-Bamfo's Nkyinkim installation at the National Memorial for Peace and Justice, Montgomery.
NkyinkimKwame Akoto-Bamfo's figures in chains stand at the entrance, before the eight hundred hanging steel columns — one for every county with a documented lynching.

Opened in 2018 by the Equal Justice Initiative, and the most serious attempt the United States has made to build the kind of memorial that Germany built. The museum occupies a warehouse where enslaved people were held for sale, a few hundred yards from the dock and the rail station where they arrived, and it runs the argument forward without a break: slavery, the domestic trade, lynching, segregation, mass incarceration.

The memorial sits on six acres on a hill above the city. Eight hundred weathered steel columns, each carrying the names of people lynched in one county between 1877 and 1950, hang from the roof as the floor slopes away beneath them, so that you begin walking among them and end walking underneath. Duplicate columns lie in a field outside, waiting for the counties themselves to come and claim them. Some have.

Give it a full day, and do the museum first. It is harrowing and it is extremely well made, and it is the single stop in this volume that most changes what the rest of it looks like.

Time: A full day for both · Best for: What the surrender did not settle · Note: Book ahead; the museum is on the site of a slave warehouse
xviii.

Wallace · Louisiana

Whitney Plantation

Whitney Plantation, Wallace, Louisiana.

On the west bank of the Mississippi in the parishes between Baton Rouge and New Orleans, and the only plantation museum in the United States built from the ground up to tell the story from the point of view of the enslaved. It opened in 2014, funded by a lawyer who bought the property for a different purpose and changed his mind.

The tour is organised around the Federal Writers' Project interviews of the 1930s, and around children: terracotta figures of the enslaved children of the property stand in the church, and the Wall of Honor carries the names of the people enslaved here. The sugar economy of the river parishes was the most lethal form of slavery in North America — the work was industrial, the season was brutal, and the mortality rate meant the population did not reproduce itself.

Nearby is the site of the 1811 German Coast uprising, the largest revolt of enslaved people in United States history, in which several hundred marched on New Orleans and were dispersed, tried and executed, with heads set on poles along the river road. There is a memorial at Whitney. Almost nothing marks the route.

Time: Half a day · Best for: The sugar country · Combine with: New Orleans, 50 miles downriver

The western theatre

The war was won here, and hardly anybody visits. The Mississippi valley and the Tennessee river line decided the outcome while the eastern armies were producing the memorable battles, and the ratio of significance to tourist numbers is the most favourable in the volume.

xix.

Shiloh · Tennessee

Shiloh National Military Park

Shiloh National Military Park, Tennessee.
ShilohTwenty-three thousand casualties on the 6th and 7th of April 1862 — more than all previous American wars combined.

Two days in April 1862 on a wooded bluff above the Tennessee, and the battle that told both countries what they had started. Around 23,700 casualties — more than the Revolution, 1812 and Mexico put together — in a place nobody had heard of, named for a log church whose name means place of peace.

Albert Sidney Johnston attacked Grant's unentrenched camps at dawn on the 6th and came close to driving them into the river. He bled to death in the afternoon from a wound behind the knee, probably from his own men's fire, with a tourniquet in his pocket. The Union line held through the evening in the thickets of the Hornet's Nest, Buell's army arrived overnight, and the second day was a Confederate retreat.

Shiloh is remote, quiet, heavily wooded, and about as close to unaltered as a battlefield gets. The Bloody Pond and the sunken road are easy to find; the National Cemetery above the landing is where to end. Corinth, Mississippi, twenty miles south — the rail junction the whole battle was about — has an excellent Park Service interpretive centre and a contraband camp site where several thousand freed people organised their own town.

Time: Half a day · Best for: The moment the scale changed · Note: Remote; two hours from Memphis or Nashville
xx.

Vicksburg · Mississippi

Vicksburg National Military Park

Vicksburg National Military Park, Mississippi.
VicksburgThe surrender on the 4th of July 1863 cut the Confederacy in two and gave the Union the Mississippi.

The bluffs that closed the Mississippi, and the object of the most inventive campaign of the war. Grant spent the winter of 1862–63 failing at it in half a dozen expensive ways, then in April ran the batteries at night, crossed below the city, cut loose from his supply line, marched inland, beat two separate armies in five engagements in seventeen days, and turned back to invest the place from the landward side.

The siege lasted forty-seven days. The garrison and the civilian population ate mules and rats and lived in caves dug into the loess bluffs, and the city surrendered on the 4th of July 1863 — the day after Gettysburg ended. Vicksburg fell, Port Hudson followed five days later, and the Confederacy was cut in two along its whole length. Lincoln wrote that the Father of Waters again went unvexed to the sea.

The park's sixteen-mile tour road runs along both lines, with 1,300 monuments among them and the Illinois memorial as the grandest. The salvaged ironclad USS Cairo, sunk by an electrically detonated mine in 1862 and raised in 1964, sits under a canopy near the cemetery and is the best-preserved Civil War warship anywhere.

Time: A full day · Best for: The campaign that won the war · Note: 16-mile driving tour; the USS Cairo is on site
xxi.

Chattanooga · Tennessee

Chickamauga and Chattanooga

Lookout Mountain above Chattanooga, Tennessee.

The rail hub that opened the way into Georgia, and the fighting for it in September and November 1863. Chickamauga, just over the Georgia line, was the Confederacy's last great victory in the west and its second-bloodiest battle: Longstreet's corps, arriving by a twelve-day rail journey from Virginia, went through a gap accidentally opened in the Union line and broke it, and George Thomas held the ridge long enough to save the army and acquire a nickname.

The Union army fell back into Chattanooga and was besieged there until Grant arrived, opened the Cracker Line, and in late November broke out — up Lookout Mountain in the fog, and then up the face of Missionary Ridge in an assault that went further than anyone had ordered and carried the crest.

This was the first national military park, established in 1890 by veterans of both armies, and the model for all the others. Point Park on Lookout Mountain has the view that explains the campaign, and the Chickamauga field is large, wooded and very quiet.

Time: A full day · Best for: The gateway to Georgia · Note: The oldest national military park, established 1890
xxii.

Atlanta · Georgia

The Atlanta History Center and the Cyclorama

Ruins of the railroad depot at Atlanta, Georgia, 1864.
Atlanta, 1864George Barnard's photograph of the depot, blown up as Sherman left the city in November. The battlefields are under the modern streets; this is what is left to look at.

Atlanta's battlefields are beneath the city, so the campaign has to be seen through what the city made of it. The Cyclorama — a 371-foot, 49-foot-high panorama of the Battle of Atlanta painted in Milwaukee in 1886 — moved to the History Center in 2017 and was restored and rehung in 2019 at a cost of some $36 million.

The restoration is the interesting part. The painting was made as a piece of northern commercial entertainment celebrating a Union victory, then bought by Atlanta and progressively altered to suit southern sensibilities, including a figure repainted to resemble Clark Gable after 1939. The History Center restored the 1886 image and then interpreted the alterations as evidence, which is exactly the right decision and rare.

The campaign itself ran from May to September 1864 and was Sherman's methodical flanking of Johnston down from Chattanooga, then Hood's costly attempt to reverse it. The fall of Atlanta on the 2nd of September 1864 re-elected Lincoln, and the re-election ended the last Confederate hope, which was not military victory but a negotiated peace with a different president.

Time: Half a day · Best for: A painting that is itself the subject · Note: The battlefield is under the city

Prison, the march, and the carving

Three sites that between them hold the worst thing the Confederacy did to prisoners, the campaign that broke its will, and the largest monument the Lost Cause ever built.

xxiii.

Andersonville · Georgia

Andersonville National Historic Site

Andersonville National Historic Site, Georgia.
Camp SumterNearly 13,000 of some 45,000 Union prisoners died here in fourteen months. The site is now the national memorial to all American prisoners of war.

A stockade of twenty-six acres, opened in February 1864 to hold 10,000 men and holding over 32,000 by August, with one creek running through it for water and sanitation both, no shelter issued, and no barracks. Nearly 13,000 of the roughly 45,000 men held here died in fourteen months, mostly of dysentery, scurvy and diarrhoea.

The causes are argued about and the argument has two honest halves. The Confederacy in 1864 was short of food and medicine for its own armies and in no position to feed prisoners well; and the exchange cartel had broken down precisely because the Confederate government refused to exchange captured black soldiers as soldiers, which was a policy decision with a predictable cost in white prisoners' lives on both sides. Northern camps had their own scandal at Elmira, at a much lower rate and with far less excuse.

Henry Wirz, the camp commandant, was tried and hanged in November 1865 — the only Confederate officer executed for war crimes, on a trial that would not meet modern standards. The site is now the national memorial to American prisoners of war of every conflict, and the museum treats the subject with unusual care.

Time: Half a day · Best for: The prisoner question · Note: Also the National Prisoner of War Museum
xxiv.

Savannah · Georgia

Fort Pulaski and Savannah

Fort Pulaski National Monument, Georgia.

Fort Pulaski, on an island at the mouth of the Savannah river, is where nineteenth-century fortification ended. Its seven-and-a-half-foot brick walls were considered impregnable — Robert E. Lee, who had worked on them as a young engineer, said so. On the 10th and 11th of April 1862 Union batteries on Tybee Island, a mile away, opened with ten experimental rifled guns and breached the wall in thirty hours. Every masonry coastal fort in the world was obsolete by the end of that week. The breach and its patch are still visible.

Savannah itself was the end of the March to the Sea. Sherman entered on the 21st of December 1864 and offered the city to Lincoln as a Christmas present. It was not burned; the mayor surrendered it and the squares survive, which is why Savannah looks the way it does and Columbia does not.

In the Green-Meldrim House on Madison Square, on the 12th of January 1865, Sherman and Stanton met twenty black ministers and asked them what the freed people wanted. Garrison Frazier answered that they wanted land. Four days later Sherman issued Special Field Order 15, setting aside the coastal strip from Charleston to the St Johns in forty-acre allotments. Andrew Johnson reversed it within the year.

Time: A day for both · Best for: The end of masonry, and the end of the march · Note: Fort Pulaski is 15 miles east of the city
xxv.

Stone Mountain · Georgia

Stone Mountain

The carving on the north face of Stone Mountain, Georgia.
Stone MountainThree acres of bas-relief, begun in 1923, abandoned, and finished in 1972. The Klan was refounded on the summit in 1915.

A granite dome east of Atlanta carrying the largest bas-relief in the world: Davis, Lee and Jackson on horseback across three acres of the north face, the carved surface deeper than the length of a car.

The chronology is the exhibit. The second Ku Klux Klan was founded on the summit on Thanksgiving night 1915, with a burning cross, weeks after the release of The Birth of a Nation. Carving began in 1923 under Gutzon Borglum, who left to carve Mount Rushmore; the project collapsed and the mountain sat half-worked for a generation. The state of Georgia bought it in 1958, four years after Brown v. Board of Education, and the carving was completed in 1972. The same legislature that funded the purchase had added the Confederate battle flag to the state flag in 1956.

It is now a state park with a laser show, a cable car and several million visitors a year, and by state law the carving cannot be altered. Go, look at the dates, and note that the thing was finished within living memory of people now in their fifties. Nothing else in this volume makes the argument about monuments as plainly.

Time: Half a day · Best for: The scale of the memory · Note: A state park with a theme park attached
xxvi.

New Orleans · Louisiana

New Orleans

Jackson Square, New Orleans, Louisiana.

The Confederacy's largest city and its greatest early loss. Farragut ran the forts below the city in April 1862 and took it without a siege, fourteen months into the war, which cost the Confederacy its port, its biggest population centre and the mouth of its river at a stroke. Benjamin Butler's occupation government followed, along with the General Order No. 28 on the women of the city that made him the most hated man in the South and got him denounced by name in the House of Commons.

Occupied New Orleans is also where the future was rehearsed early: black regiments raised from 1862, a free black Creole community with property and French newspapers agitating for the vote from 1863, and after the war the Mechanics' Institute massacre of 1866 and the White League's armed coup attempt at Liberty Place in 1874. The Liberty Place monument, which had carried an inscription celebrating white supremacy, was the first of the four statues the city removed in 2017; Lee, Davis and Beauregard followed within six weeks, under threats serious enough that the contractors worked at night in body armour.

The Cabildo on Jackson Square holds the state's war collection, including one of the four surviving copies of the Emancipation Proclamation signed by Lincoln. Lee Circle is still called Lee Circle by most people, and the column is empty.

Time: Two days · Best for: Occupation, and removal · Note: The Cabildo holds the state museum's war collection